Why 0% Are Doing AI But Only 0% Are Winning?

AI is everywhere, but excellence is still rare.

AI Adoption Remains Unparallelled In just four years, artificial intelligence has transformed from a niche capability embraced by roughly half of organizations to a mainstream business reality deployed by 78% of companies worldwide. This represents the fastest technology adoption curve in modern business history—faster even than the internet or mobile computing.

McKinsey counts an enterprise as an adopter when respondents say AI is “used in at least one business function”—from isolated pilots to full-scale deployments.

Current Position:

78% adoption in 2024 (up from 55% in 2023)

By end of 2026:

Projected to reach 92% adoption, but maturity remains the challenge

AI Maturity Reality Check Accenture applies a dual‐index model - Foundational capabilities (cloud, data governance, architecture), and Differentiation capabilities (C-suite sponsorship, talent model, innovation culture).
Firms in the top quartile on both indexes are labelled AI Achievers (12% globally, 7% in NA)

Genpact’s tracker surveys executives annually; it classifies only 5% as GenAI Pioneers yet finds 61% already earmark ≀10% of tech budgets for GenAI and 74% expect tangible productivity gains within 24 months—evidence that spending is lock-in, not hype.

70%
Experimentation Phase
25%
Basic Implementation
5%
Mature Programs

The laggards: 45% of respondents have no GenAI plans or spending


Fast followers: 27% are in planning stages, while only 5% are pioneers, already committing significant tech spend to GenAI or deploying it across multiple parts of their business

Breaking Down Adoption By Sector McKinsey’s July-2024 cross-tab shows share of respondents using AI in ≄1 function by industry:
Technology 88%, Financial Services 65%, Healthcare 63%, Manufacturing/Energy 59%

Accenture then overlays maturity: Technology 41% Achiever, Financial 1%, Healthcare 3%, Manufacturing/Energy 9%.

Adoption Rate
Maturity Rate

The leader: Technology leads adoption at 88% but only 41% mature

Regulations laced laggard: Financial Services: 65% adoption, only 1% mature

The Next 24 Months Will Decide Organizations have approximately 24 months to establish AI competitive positioning before market dynamics create irreversible disadvantages. This timeline reflects several converging factors:
  • 1. Technology Maturation: Affordability and accessibility of AI capabilities through cloud platforms and pre-trained models
  • 2. Market Expectation Reset: Customer and stakeholder expectations are shifting rapidly as AI-enhanced experiences become standard
  • 3. Talent Migration: The best AI professionals gravitate toward organizations with mature AI programs and ambitious transformation agendas
  • 4. Regulatory Stabilization: Government frameworks for AI governance are crystallizing globally

78% Adoption
5% Achievers

Key Challenges

  • Data Quality Issues (46%)
  • Talent Scarcity (33%)
  • Strategic Planning Gaps

How Leaders Fare on Key Metrics vs Laggards Protiviti correlates maturity to financial outcomes: at Stage 5 (Transformation) 95% report high satisfaction and 75% say ROI exceeds expectations; at Stages 1-2 fewer than 30% exceed ROI. The Protiviti AI Pulse Survey provides additional granularity, identifying five stages of AI maturity:
  • Stage 1 - Initial (19%): Limited understanding, no strategic initiatives
  • Stage 2 - Experimentation (32%): Small-scale pilots and proof-of-concepts
  • Stage 3 - Defined (21%): AI integrated into existing business processes
  • Stage 4 - Optimization (20%): Enhanced AI systems with continuous improvement
  • Stage 5 - Transformation (8%): AI drives significant business transformation

Experimenting Stage
Developing Stage
Scaling Stage
Leading Stage

Where Companies Stall Genpact's research with 550 senior executives identifies the primary barriers that trap organizations in perpetual pilot mode- Data Infrastructure Crisis: (46% of leaders), Talent Scarcity: (33%), Strategic Ambiguity: (74%)

Only organizations with mature responsible AI frameworks successfully scale beyond proof-of-concepts. Most enterprises lack the policy infrastructure needed to deploy AI safely and systematically across business functions

Pilot to Production

65%

Struggle to scale beyond initial proof of concepts

Data Integration

58%

Cannot integrate AI with existing data infrastructure

ROI Measurement

47%

Fail to demonstrate clear business value

Change Management

43%

Unable to drive organizational adoption

Why They Stall

Data Quality Issues

46%

Poor data foundation undermines AI effectiveness

Talent Scarcity

33%

Lack of skilled AI professionals

Strategic Planning Gaps

29%

No clear AI strategy or roadmap

Technology Integration

24%

Difficulty integrating with legacy systems

Budget Constraints

21%

Insufficient funding for AI initiatives

What Drives Success Five strategic imperatives emerge for senior leadership:
  • 1. Treat AI as CEO-Level Transformation: 83% of AI Achievers have formal CEO/Board AI sponsorship compared to 56% of experimenters.
  • 2. Invest in Platform-Level Capabilities: Organizations must move beyond point solutions to build integrated AI capabilities.
  • 3. Develop Blended Talent Models: The most in-demand capability combines business domain expertise with technical AI fluency.
  • 4. Implement Responsible AI from Day One: Organizations with mature responsible AI programs are 53% more likely to achieve successful scaling.
  • 5. Measure and Celebrate Business Outcomes: Companies that track solution-level KPIs are significantly more likely to beat ROI targets.

AI Maturity Stages

High Impact
95%

High satisfaction at highest AI maturity stage

Protiviti AI Pulse Survey 2024

ROI Expectations Achievement

High Impact
75%

Exceed ROI expectations at highest maturity stage

Protiviti AI Pulse Survey 2024

Data Quality Foundation

Foundation
46%

Addressing the #1 barrier cited by organizations

Genpact GenAI Countdown 2024

Talent Development

Medium Impact
33%

Strategic response to talent scarcity affecting organizations

Genpact GenAI Countdown 2024

GenAI Value Creation

Medium Impact
74%

Organizations expect GenAI value creation within 2 years

Genpact GenAI Countdown 2024

Strategic Planning Framework

Foundation
Critical

Structured approach to move from experimentation to maturity

Cross-study Analysis

Be in the 27% come 2027

The 24-Month Window for AI Leadership
24
Month Window
83%
Achievers already have CEO/Board sponsorship vs. 56% of Experimenters
Accenture Art of AI Maturity
61%
Enterprises have already redirected up to 10% of their total tech budget into GenAI
KPMG AI Advisory
280x
Inference costs for GPT-3.5-level performance have fallen in 18 months
Stanford AI Index 2025

Sources & References

QR Code
Download Full Report (PDF)

McKinsey State of AI 2024

Comprehensive analysis of AI adoption across industries

Stanford AI Index 2025

Investment trends and market analysis

Genpact GenAI Countdown 2024

Maturity assessment and implementation barriers

Protiviti AI Pulse Survey 2024

Satisfaction rates and ROI expectations

Accenture Art of AI Maturity

Sector-specific maturity benchmarks

IBM The ingenuity of GenAI

Cross-industry implementation patterns
✅ Insights copied to clipboard!